User talk:Neff

Welcome to StrategyWiki!
Hello Neff! Welcome to StrategyWiki. Thank you for your contributions. If you have any questions, just contact a sysop through their talk page or post on the staff lounge, and they'd be happy to help. If you need help editing, check the StrategyWiki Guide or visit the Discord server to chat. On the other hand, if you have ideas for StrategyWiki, bring them up on the staff lounge as well. To keep up-to-date with the goings on of the wiki, consider adding the noticeboard to your watchlist.

Please remember to sign your name when leaving comments on talk pages by clicking or using four tildes (    ); this will automatically produce your name and the date. Feel free to delete this message from your talk page if you like, or keep it for reference. Happy editing! — Prod (talk) 01:34, 26 July 2023 (UTC)

Final Fantasy names
With all of the name changes that you are making, how are you making sure that players who are playing the NES or PSX versions of the game understand which spell names and locations you are referring to? It's not OK to make the guides specific to one particular version of the game, the guide must be accessible to any player playing any version of the game. NES players do not know what Curaga or Curaja are because those spells don't have those names in the game. How do you propose to overcome this problem?  Pro cyon  00:39, 2 August 2023 (UTC)
 * I feel we need a page which has a lookup table of all the different names from the different versions. We stick to one version of naming (first official localization) and we can maybe add a reference/link to the version naming page? -- Prod (talk) 01:37, 2 August 2023 (UTC)
 * I am aware that my approach isn't ideal. I assumed that the lastest names for spells were going to be used in this wiki, mainly because on the 'Black magic' and 'White magic' pages those names are at the top of each table (under spell listings) and bold faced.
 * When I looked at other pages for Final Fantasy I found that sometimes the NES names, sometimes the PSX names and other times the GBA names were used. The issue you mentioned (NES players do not know what Curaga or Curaja are because those spells don't have those names in the game.) was present before, just the other way around. I simply was trying to make it more consistent. In addition, most of the edits I made to the spell names were links to the respective pages, so you could look up what each spell is, if you were unsure: The 'Black magic' and 'White magic' pages list 3 names for the spells and the links I edited link to the sections directly.
 * I like the idea of a lookup table. We would have to decide which version of names we are going to use (I don't care which one) and stay consistent. Where do you add the link to the lookup table page though? Neff (talk) 13:55, 2 August 2023 (UTC)
 * Another reason for updating the spell names was that links didn't work properly when the old names were used. For example: Cure4 doesn't link to the right section, but Curaja does. Neff (talk) 14:01, 2 August 2023 (UTC)
 * I found the Control_selector template and was wondering if we could use this? You would choose the version of game you're playing which would then change the spell names etc. on the page. But it would have to display "select game" instead of "select controller". That would be the best solution in my opinion, but I don't know if it's possible. Neff (talk) 18:25, 2 August 2023 (UTC)
 * I'm not sure I like the idea of using Control selector. It's primarily for controller buttons, where you can see visually it's the wrong system and change it. With differing names, especially some which are completely different, it may not be obvious to users which version they're on, or that they should change it. One possibility is having a reference . Another possibility is to put the alt names in a hover, similar to nihongo (see example). Regarding which version, probably the first localized version is the most appropriate based on our usual policies, this way we don't have to keep updating the guide every time a new game changes the names. But the latest release is probably the most useful to users. To add a page with a lookup table, you can add a new link to the Table of Contents page. -- Prod (talk) 21:20, 2 August 2023 (UTC)


 * Thank you for the reply. I'm trying to figure out how this nihongo template works ... one (two) ... it just puts the alternate names in parenthesis? How do I create a link then? CUR4 (Cure4) this doesn't work..


 * This seems to work: CUR4 (Cure4)
 * But then we would have to write all 3 (or more) names of every item, spell, location etc. every time a name comes up, which would make the pages more difficult to read. Imagine this (from the Black magic page):
 * Level 2: TMPR (Steel), ICE (Ice1)*, DARK (Fog)
 * TMPR (Steel) raises the attack power of a character in your party, which makes it a spell that you should use against every boss you encounter. It is also stackable, so the character's attack can go higher and higher. Note: TMPR (Steel) is bugged in the NES version, and does nothing. ICE (Ice1) is quite a bit more powerful than the Fire and Thunder spells, Blizzard will be very useful before you get ICE2 (Ice2). DARK (Fog) inflicts the "Blind" status and reduces the likelihood of an enemy attack, however it has little effect when it works. ICE (Ice1) deals more damage than Fire or Thunder, but if you cast instead TMPR (Steel) on two allies the party will deal definitely more damage.


 * I'm not sure what the best solution is. Maybe a reference is the way to go. But again: do we put a reference in for every mention of the name? Neff (talk) 23:27, 2 August 2023 (UTC)
 * That template is just an example. We'd make a custom template for this specifically. So it looks like?, or this, or even a combination of both. We could even put it all in a template which would automatically enter the right term based on the lookup tables. I think the first step though is to create the page with the comparison. I'd suggest Final Fantasy/Versions. -- Prod (talk) 04:30, 3 August 2023 (UTC)