Talk:Pokémon Red and Blue/Pallet Town

Niggles
I like what's been done so far, but I have some niggles to raise: Hope this helps. I'm going to dive straight in and sort out the table border issues, as I think they should be changed regardless of any opposition. I'll see if I can get some use out of prettytable. --DrBob (Talk) 05:35, 10 February 2007 (CST)
 * Why is the text larger than normal? This just creates inconsistency with other guides, and doesn't look too good either.
 * The titles for the Pokémon information boxes at the bottom are inconsistent and don't stand out enough. They should probably be bold and centred.
 * Similarly, the borders on said information boxes are so very 1990s. They should be standardised with the other tables on the wiki: a single one-pixel grey border.
 * The "Starting Pokémon" box at the top could be improved by having "Starting Pokémon" as a header row, then the different colours, then the rest. It also needs its borders sorted.
 * Is there any reason that these images aren't thumbnailed and captioned? It's just my opinion here, but I think thumnailed images look better, and fit in with the rest of the page better. They also allow the user to specify how big they want the thumbnails to be.
 * OK. I've migrated it all to prettytable, and fixed a few things, but I've also broken the tables at the bottom slightly. I propose that they be redone as one table instead of two, using two columns and headers effectively. I guess that a while was spent making these tables the way they are, so I'll leave it for the moment to get some feedback. --DrBob (Talk) 06:05, 10 February 2007 (CST)

Pokémon Yellow
Why is information on Pokémon Yellow being included in this guide, when we've already got a Pokémon Yellow guide? Are they being moved around (again)? --DrBob (Talk) 11:35, 10 February 2007 (CST)


 * As per this discussion (which I admit was never truly formally concluded) it came down to redundancy of information. Since 90% of what applies to R&B applies to Y, why duplicate more than half of the guide for the sake of one game?  I set up a What's new guide for Yellow, and linked R&B's TOC to Y's.  We could decide once and for all that it should be R/B/Y just as the second gen is G/S/C, or we could leave Yellow as it's own main page and point to the same guide.  Personally, I don't mind how we choose to organize the main pages either way, but it would be extremely wasteful to have two copies of nearly identical walkthroughs as seperate instances. Procyon 11:48, 10 February 2007 (CST)
 * Right. I was having a stupid moment. :-P --DrBob (Talk) 11:52, 10 February 2007 (CST)