Gun/Weapons

Weapons are broken down into seven main groups. Select your weapon using the saddlebag menu from the Pause menu.

Pistols
Pistols are best from close to mid-range, have a fast rate of fire, a fairly quick reload time and cause medium damage.

Colt Navy Revolver 1851

 * Found: On you at start of game
 * Damage: 3
 * Fire Rate: 4
 * Reload: 6

Schofield

 * Found: After talking with Jenny
 * Damage: 4
 * Fire Rate: 5
 * Reload: 7

Volcanic 10

 * Found: After killing Webb & Rudabaugh
 * Damage: 6
 * Fire Rate: 7
 * Reload: 8

Dual Peacemakers

 * Found: After Killing Hoodoo
 * Damage: 6
 * Fire Rate: 9
 * Reload: 10

Rifles
Rifles are best from medium to long-range have a medium rate of fire, a medium reload time and cause mid to high damage.

Winchester 1866

 * Found: On you at start of game
 * Damage: 6
 * Fire Rate: 2
 * Reload: 4

Ferguson

 * Found: After killing Hollister
 * Damage: 9
 * Fire Rate: 8
 * Reload: 6

Shotguns
Shotguns are best from close range, have a slow rate of fire and a medium reload time, but cause high damage.

Shotgun Model 1887

 * Found: After killing Crude
 * Damage: 8
 * Fire Rate: 5
 * Reload: 3

Colt Double Barrel

 * Found: After killing Webb & Rudabaugh
 * Damage: 10
 * Fire Rate: 6
 * Reload: 4

Nock Gun

 * Found: After killing Magruder
 * Damage: 10
 * Fire Rate: 6
 * Reload: 4

Cannon Nock Gun

 * Found: After completing all missions and main storyline.
 * Damage: 10
 * Fire Rate: 6
 * Reload: 4

Sharpshooters
Sharpshooters are best from long range, have a slow rate of fire and cause high damage.

Sharps 1874

 * Found: When the Renegades attack Clay's camp.
 * Damage: 8
 * Fire Rate: 3
 * Reload: 6

Remington

 * Found: After saving Soapy in Dodge
 * Damage: 9
 * Fire Rate: 5
 * Reload: 6

Mêlée
Mêlée weapons are best at close range, have a fast rate of fire with no reload time and cause high damage.

Bowie Knife

 * Found: On you at start of game, even when all other weapons have been lost you keep this knife
 * Damage: 5
 * Fire Rate: 10
 * Reload: N/A

Quick Killer's Tomahawk

 * Found: After killing Quick Killer
 * Damage: 6
 * Fire Rate: 10
 * Reload: N/A

Cavalry Sword

 * Found: After killing Reed
 * Damage: 6
 * Fire Rate: 10
 * Reload: N/A

Thrown
Thrown weapons are best from mid-range, have a medium rate of fire with no reload time and cause very high explosive damage.

Whiskey Bomb

 * Found: After Killing Crude
 * Damage: 6
 * Fire Rate: 9
 * Reload: N/A

Dynamite

 * Found: After following Port to his hideout
 * Damage: 10
 * Fire Rate: 9
 * Reload: N/A

Bows
Bows are silent weapons best from close- to mid-range, have a fast rate of fire, no reload time and cause mid to high damage.

Apache Bow

 * Found: After escaping from the jail
 * Damage: 3
 * Fire Rate: 6
 * Reload: 6

Blackfoot Fire Bow

 * Found: After escaping from the fort
 * Damage: 5
 * Fire Rate: 6
 * Reload: 8

Loco Dynamite Bow

 * Found: After following Soapy to use the cross
 * Damage: 10
 * Fire Rate: 6
 * Reload: 8