Talk:Kingdom Hearts

Keyblades & Other Weapons
Made a rather large change to the Keyblades page. I turned the long lists into sortable tables. In my mind this has two benefits: Hope you like it. - naj zere 20:47, 3 October 2008 (UTC)
 * 1) The table of contents is much cleaner
 * 2) Readers can find what they're looking for alphabetically or by hit points, etc.

The page overall
I see that a lot of work has gone into writing about this game. This guide is really looking more like one you'd find on Wikipedia though. I get the feeling that StrategyWiki is where readers will come for information on beating their game, not so much to get background info on it. I think this page has lost focus on its main function, which is to inform readers on in-game information.

A lot of the information on this page has nothing to do with beating the game, and is essentially a reproduction of the Wikipedia article. I'm not going to start making a bunch of elisions, but I do think it would be appropriate for the content's creators to do some pruning. My two cents anyway. - naj zere 21:09, 3 October 2008 (UTC)


 * Well, if you take a look at the page history you'll notice that the majority of the content was directly copied from the Wikipedia article (by me). I tend to do this to articles to get them started; as an empty page seems much more disappointing than one that is rich (even if it is overwhelming or excessive). Also, you'll notice the cleanup tag on the right side, below the Toolbox, indicating that this is already a recognized issue that needs to be addressed by revising the page. Removing unrelated content (or subpaging other content) is definitely the first thing that needs to be done. -- 23:16, 3 October 2008 (UTC)


 * Also, one of the reasons I copy the Wikipedia article is to allow users like you to clean them up - because it's more difficult for you to add it yourself. -- 23:17, 3 October 2008 (UTC)