The contents of the box[edit]
Picking up where they left off, in the courtroom, the small box that's been retrieved from Windibank's Pawnbrokery has turned out to be a music box. Inspector Gregson objects to the music disc being played, but the prosecutor is unfazed and allows it to happen anyway. But once it finally plays, it's just singular notes! Is there more to this than meets the eye? Ashley Graydon laughs it off, believing that he's been vindicated and saying the music box is "broken".
At the prompt, choose It could be a clue. Then, select the third option, Not supposed to be music. Suddenly Mr. Graydon is not amused anymore, but you will still be asked to provide evidence to explain what's going on here. Iris examines the box and reassures you, it's not broken but for some reason it was specifically made to be only able to play a single note. How curious, right?
Before presenting the evidence, examine Today's Paper! You might have come across this without a second thought, and in this case, examine it now, turn it around and check the back where the news are upside down. You will be updated about a leak in secret communications between Great Britain's Ministry of Justice and its allies. The plot thickens. The details of today's paper have been updated in the Court Record. Now present Today's Paper.
In conclusion, the contents of the music box appear to be a message in Morse code. Also, the communications office that deals with such high-level communications is the one that employs Mr. Graydon and Juror 5. Two months ago, a negotiation went underway inside the omnibus for the information contained in the disk, but the item ended up unclaimed at the pawnbrokery. If anyone found it before it made its way out of the country, the person responsible for creating it in the first place would be in pretty big danger, so the culprit had to recover it at all costs and everything is pointing to Ashley Graydon as the mole who made this all possible.
Defiant, Graydon is asked to testify to counter these accusations, and as a surprise, the Skulkin brothers came back to testify again alongside Inspector Gregson.
Graydon, Nash and Ringo's Testimony: Graydon's Counter[edit]
- Graydon: A mere communications officer couldn't possibly steal confidential government information!
- Graydon: Besides, the sounds produced by that music box aren't even Morse code!
- Graydon: It was some low-class brickmaker negotiating with McGilded anyway, was it not? I've no relation to the man!
- Nash: Look, all we dun is break into the gaff the other night like wot 'e told us to do!
- Ringo: If we'd known there woz dodgy gov'ment secrets involved, we wouldn't 'ave touched it!
Graydon's Counter: Cross Examination[edit]
The Skulkin brothers have finally admitting to breaking and entering, unaware of any "conspiracies" behind it, and also admit that Mr. Graydon was with them, even though he denies it. The Small Music Box will be added to the Court Record.
Press statement 1 to learn from a very star struck Juror 5 that Mr. Graydon is actually the leader of a team in charge of setting up and testing every single one of the telegraphs used by the ministry. Not only that, but he works closely with the ministry itself and is one of the best code-crackers she knows. Graydon doesn't seem happy about her giving away this info.
Now, press statement 2. Graydon and the accusation claim that the sounds in he music box disk aren't Morse code because it's impossible to discern between the dots and dashes that form a message in said code. Graydon is happy and laughing again, but not for long.
When prompted, choose option 2, "Give it a try", to try and prove that Morse code can be played with this music box. You will be sent to the examining screen. Check the button on the bottom of the box again and present the other side of the music box. Unfortunately, since we don't have a second music disk at the moment with which we can prove our Morse code theory, the music box will have to be set aside for later.
Let's go back to the cross examination. Press statement 4 and, when prompted, pursue Ringo Skulkin. They will tell you that they have known Graydon from long ago, because he grew up in the same area as them and he used to be poor. However, he was clever from a very young age and would come up with ideas the Skulkin brother could never even imagine themselves. When asked, choose option 1, "Add it to the testimony", and a new statement about what you just heard will be added.
Now press the new statement. When it asks you if you want them to elaborate select option 2, "The business name", if you want to progress the story. You can choose option 1 too, but the only thing you will get from it is some fun backstory.
Once the plot moves on, you will pose an interesting question: if the milk delivery scheme was run by the Skulkin brothers and Graydon, where did the "Milverton" part of the name come from? You might guess where this is going. Of course, Graydon doesn't accept anything the brothers are saying and doesn't want them to keep talking, but there's nothing he can do. As it turns out, Graydon's family was very poor and his father struggled so much with money that his mother walked out on them. She took the Graydon surname then, but Ashley's surname before then was Milverton. He denies it, but Van Zieks points out that he works for the ministry, and as such, his personal details are recorded and can be checked at any moment. Unsurprisingly, the Skulkin brothers are telling the truth.
But what does all of this have to do with the current case? Graydon wasn't riding that omnibus two months ago and there's nothing linking him to that case, present the McGilded Case Notes on statement 3. If you've checked out the notes previously, then you might have noticed something that's very convenient for us right now. "Thrice-Fired" Mason's real name was Mason Milverton. The victim from the omnibus case was Mr. Graydon's very own father!
The defence's theory is that Ashley Graydon was stealing confidential information from the ministry, encoding it in music box disks sets of two for safety, and selling it to McGilded through his father Mason to make ends meet. One of their deals went awry, and Mason met his end inside the omnibus. The disk that was present in that crime scene that night was the one that ended up being seized by Inspector Gregson, and is in your Court Record now. You also believe the missing disk was stuck inside the music box, and that it was stolen by Graydon on the night Mr. Windibank was shot.
Of course, Graydon denies the truth, but has been gesturing so much that now there's blood seeping through the left sleeve of his coat. There's no need to examine him for bullet wounds anymore! Ashley Graydon will finally admit to being at the crime scene that night and sustaining a bullet wound.
The next mystery to unravel is upon us: if Windibank's gunshot hit Graydon, and the brothers's shot hit Sholmes, where's the gun from which the fatal bullet was shot? The only logical conclusion is that the third intruder, Graydon, was also armed, and was the one to shoot at Mr. Windibank. However, Graydon is not going down without a fight! In another twist, he will now claim to have witnessed the moment in which Gina shot Mr. Windibank. He testifies that he has seen all this through the peephole in which he'll give out his statements for the court! Could this get anymore worse?
Graydon's Testimony: The Moment of the Shooting[edit]
- While these ruffians were jostling with the broker, I was still near the entrance to the shop.
- When Windibank threw Nash over the counter, I felt a sharp pain in my arm.
- I pursued the man but he shut himself in the storeroom. I could see him through the peephole in the door, though.
- The accused, in a black coat, shot the man in the back as he was trying to flee to safety!
- I saw the blood spatter all over that wretched girl.
- Then she tossed the gun out of the peephole. So I picked it up...and made my escape.
The Moment of the Shooting: Cross Examination[edit]
While listening to Graydon, you might have noticed a few inconsistencies that don't quite click with the facts we know up until now. However, thanks to Van Zieks's knowledge about modern German scientific progress, Gina's black overcoat will be tested to prove that it's bathed in human blood. You know it's not Windibank's, but since the court doesn't believe in Iris's blood sample, you just knew nobody will believe it's not from the victim. If you don't uncover something decisive while the test is run, it will be over for Gina.
You will have to press every statement in this testimony, and Graydon will elaborate on all of them. Nothing too surprising except a couple of comments. He will, for example, claim that it was Gina who had the third gun, and that she used it to murder the victim. Pay close attention during the sixth and last statement and pursue Nash Skulkin. The place to pursue is after you ask him if he has the second disk. The inspector will start shaking Nash for not telling him about the third gun.
But why did Inspector Gregson take his anger out on Nash? Salty though he may be, Gregson is not one for violent outbursts. Could Graydon's last statement have anything to do with the Inspector?
An errand to run[edit]
After that conversation, an officer will interrupt the cross examination and bring in the results of the blood test. Of course, it comes out positive in every sense of the word. You will still claim that the blood is Mr Mason's, but of course, nobody believes it. Van Zieks and the jury are all very disappointed in the fact that you are now calling McGilded a murderer after having defended him two months ago, knowing he can't defend himself now because he's dead. It seems the court has turned against you, close to admitting defeat.
The jury will decide Graydon's testimony is the absolute truth and will pronounce a unanimous guilty verdict. However we aren't done with the surprises yet. The officer that delivered the blood test results seems to know you. It's Herlock Sholmes himself!! Took him long enough to show up, and Iris is ecstatic.
He has an errand to run, and something to give you. It's a parting present for you, something Susato gave him the night before. Sholmes explains they both hoped matters could be settled without the need to use this gift, but it has come to this. You will unwrap the present and find the cat-flap-making machine Iris invented, or the "Cat-Flapomat" as she calls it! Sholmes will tell you that, on the night of the murder, while you went out chasing the thieves, Susato used this machine for something. He won't say what for, though, but you might see what's going on here if you've been paying attention since the beginning of this trial. The Cat-Flapomat will be added to the Court Record.
Sholmes's time in the courtroom is in five minutes is already over. Van Zieks is sure the die has been cast and there's no way for you to turn this around at this point. When asked, choose option 2, "Further cross examination". You will ask to go back to cross examining Mr. Graydon, and since the fake officer/Sholmes asked for a temporary interruption and the judge agreed to it, there's nothing wrong with doing so. However, the judge is only giving you one last chance, literally: you can only present one piece of evidence on one definitive statement. If you can't turn things around with that, the trial will be over.
Then, Sholmes will dramatically faint from the overexertion, and after he's been carried away, you will be able to have the confidence to wipe the smile off Graydon's face for good.
The Moment of the Shooting Again: Cross Examination[edit]
Present the Cat-Flapomat at either statement 3 or 6. Making cat flaps isn't the only utility this machine is good at. It can create a peephole in any door. You have recently been told that Susato made use of this contraption at the scene of the crime, shortly after you arrived in it and while you were absent, running after the thieves. Since you saw the scene of the crime through a peephole in the storeroom door, you can attest to its existence now, but until Susato created it, there wasn't any peephole there. Graydon's whole testimony is only sustained on the grounds that he watched everything happen through the peephole, so if there was no peephole back then to begin with, the whole testimony will come crashing down.
Of course, the efficiency of this contraption will be questioned. Iris, however, has taken the time to get ahead and created a cat flap in the courtroom door while you weren't looking, through which Wagahai will walk in. Also, the size of the cat flaps made by this machine are always the same, and the peephole in the storeroom door has the same measurements as the ones the Cat-Flapomat is set to.
There's another hurdle to jump now. Since Susato Mikotoba isn't here, she can't testify to having created the peephole, so to van Zieks that means you can't prove whether she did it or not. He demands when the peephole has been made. When asked by the judge, present the Photograph of Gina.
After proving the peephole wasn't there before the murder, van Zieks will point out two things. One, Susato has tampered with a crime scene and that is illegal. And two, even though Graydon has committed perjury, this doesn't prove he pulled the trigger on Mr. Windibank. But, as Iris wisely says, one lie begets another. Does this phrase ring a bell?
When prompted, you have two options:
- Choose option 2, "the peephole." That's right, if the peephole didn't yet exist at the time of the murder, and the pawnbrokery has been chock-full of police since a few minutes after the crime, how could Graydon know it was there?
- Choose option 3, "the bloodstains on the coat." Once again, if the peephole didn't exist at the time of the murder, and the coat has been in Gina's possession almost the entire time, then how could Graydon know about the bloodstains on the coat?
Did someone tell him these things? Suddenly, Inspector Gregson asks van Zieks if he could leave the court. But he was denied the chance. Has Inspector Gregson been anticipating this to escape responsibility?
Of course, when asked about who told Graydon about the peephole, present Inspector Gregson. Since he didn't know he would have to appear before this court today, Graydon couldn't have been aware of the existence of the peephole before coming into this room. He must have learned about it here, and the only person who could have told him is the inspector, in an attempt to give him some tools and information to counter any accusations. Iris remembers that they were whispering to each other during Gina's testimony, seemingly "negotiating" on the stand a while ago.
However, what does Inspector Gregson have to gain from disclosing classified information to this man he says he doesn't know? There's only one thing Gregson could have wanted from Ashley Graydon. When asked, present either the Music Box Disk or the Small Music Box. Of course, we had come to the conclusion that Graydon had stolen the other disk from the music box on the night of the crime. Inspector Gregson would've made a deal with him about the case so he could save himself from trouble, in exchange for the missing music disk. With both in his possession, the confidential information contained in them would be safe.
This theory implies something very important. The missing second disk might very well be right there inside the courtroom as van Zieks pointed out. Gregson wouldn't have agreed to the deal if he wasn't absolutely sure he was getting that disk out of it. When asked to be searched, however, he will agree, but why would he co-operate so easily? Surprising everyone, choose option 2, "Search someone else!" Gregson will protest but Iris counters that you're just doing your duty as a defence lawyer. Then, when asked about who you want to search, present Nash Skulkin, the taller brother. Gregson will then object again and will try to stop the search, but to no avail.
To everyone's surprise, your instincts turns out to be correct: the missing disk is found is Nash's pocket. You will then explain that, during Graydon's last cross examination, the inspector started acting very strangly, turned to Nash Skulkin, grabbed him and violently shook him. He used the threat as a pretense to hide the very disk in question.
However, Graydon will not admit to what he did. He admits that he lied in court, but attributes everything else to your vivid imagination. Gregson, on the other side, will ask the jury to believe in him, and believe that whatever he has done was in the best interest of justice and of all the people involved. You need to prove either that Graydon pulled the trigger, or that Gregson struck a deal with him, and you need to do it now!
When asked about who you want to present evidence first, choose option 2 or 1, Inspector Gregson or Ashley Graydon. As your final piece of evidence, present either the Small Music Box or the Music Box Disk. You want to listen to the music disk again but this time, you want to listen to both of the disks at the same time, the way they are supposed to be played. Van Zieks will agree with you, and so, the music box disks will be played, together this time. Everyone will recognize the sounds as Morse code despite the last attempt from Gregson in trying to stop this from happening to no avail.
Finally Inspector Gregson snaps, admitting to the crime. He will agree to confess to everything, if the court can stop the music box playing any further. Graydon approached him to make a deal after the recess, and for the sake of fulfilling his duty, he took it.
The whole truth[edit]
Ashley Graydon angrily snaps, breaking his walking cane and choking the inspector for breaking his silence. He will then confess to everything, and he will talk about his past life in the slums too. He will tell you that he only started selling confidential info to McGilded because he offered to pay for it, and Graydon wanted money, as much as he could get. His father Mason made the disks he then sold to McGilded, but in the end, after the amount of money Graydon was paying his father for his work, the old man realized something wasn't right. He ordered his son to let him do the next trade, or he wouldn't accept his payments anymore, and that's how he ended up in that omnibus with a knife through his belly. And so, Ashley Graydon swore revenge on McGilded. He hired someone to burn the omnibus with McGilded inside to avenge his father's death.
Then, he had to tie the one remaining loose end —part of the last set of disks he was going to sell was still out there. The first time McGilded had paid him, he did so in the form of a pawned jewel he had to retrieve and then sell for the agreed price. He guessed that McGilded would have hidden the disk in the pawnbrokery, and he would've also entrusted someone else with the ticket —in this case, Gina. Since he was present at McGilded's trial, he knew what Gina looked like, and her testimony was "peculiar", so he made a guess. However, when he followed her on the day of the deadline, she only redeemed McGilded's overcoat and disk number 1, which was in one of its pockets. The music box and disk number two had already been forfeited. When Inspector Gregson took disk number 1 with him, Graydon knew he was racing against time before the item disappears. What he was looking for had to still be inside the shop, and he had to recover those items before the police found out about them.
And so, he hired the Skulkins, his childhood friends, to break and enter the shop with him. Just as he had found and recovered disk number 2, though, Mr. Windibank caught them in the act and shot Graydon in the arm. Since he was armed too, he fired back without even thinking about it, and even though he wasn't really aiming on purpose nor did he want to hurt him, the bullet killed him instantly when the pawnbroker had already turned around to flee. Scared of his own actions, Ashley Graydon fled the scene and that was it. That was the whole truth, and the story of how Ashley Graydon hated McGilded so much that he became just like him in the end.
With the trial coming to a close, the jurors will declare a unanimous Not Guilty verdict, and so the judge will acquit Gina of a charge of murdering Windibanks. But she still has to answer for her other crime, since she lied in the McGuilded case. However, she'll be out of jail in the sequel "Resolve". Congratulations on this final case!
On a last note, Juror 5 says the sounds from the music box made no sense to her, and that it might not even be Morse code at all! Looks like it's far from over.
What really happened in both Runaway Room and Unspeakable Story[edit]
Ashley Milverton lived in the slums and used to work with the Skulkin brothers, Nash and Ringo, as a milk delivery service. He later left the slums with his mother and became a communications officer. He also took his mother's surname, Graydon. It was during this time when he met Magnus McGilded, and they struck a special deal: McGilded would buy encoded secrets from Graydon and pay him handsomely. To cover up his involvement, Graydon enlists the help of his father, "Thrice-Fired" Mason Milverton. Not knowing his son's intentions, Milverton is asked to make music disks, bringing him out of retirement. Once Graydon starts to make more money, his father becomes suspicious and decides to do business with McGilded instead.
During the trip on the omnibus with hatmaker Lay D. Furst, banker Bruce Fairplay, and the driver Beppo, with Gina hiding under the seat of McGilded, things took a turn for the worst. McGilded killed Mason with a knife, spattering his coat with Milverton's blood. the small box with the second disk in it. This caused Gina to scream, and McGilded dragged her out of the hiding spot. While McGilded questioned Gina, Lay D. Furst spotted what he believed to be Mr. McGilded coated in blood, when in reality it was Gina.
Fortunately for McGilded, while Fairplay and Furst left to the police, he made a deal with both Beppo and Gina. He asked Beppo to deposit his coat at the nearest pawnbroker, which happened to be the one located on Baker Street. He then gave gave her the ticket for the item and asked her to extend the payment in case he was occupied later. He threatened Gina should she refuse to cooperate and asked for her to lie in her testimony. McGilded was deemed innocent due to Gina's lies and their tampering of the crime scene. Both Ryunosuke and Susato unknowingly got involved because of how little prepared they are. During the trial, Graydon, in the audience, took note of Gina's appearance, correctly deducing that McGilded is threatening her into silence and may lead him back to the discs. Not only that, after the trial, he hires an imposter policeman to burn McGilded to death in the omnibus, and the incident is written off as the curse of "The Reaper."
After the case with Mr. Natsume, Graydon, under the name "Eggert Benedict," goes to Windibank's to retrieve the coat and the disks, but is only able to find the disk labeled "For McGilded" on it. Gina attempts to take it back, leaving a small blood smudge on the disk. After Ryunosuke and Susato corrected Sholmes's deductions, in which it becomes apparent that Graydon is not the coat's owner, he tried to use his gun to take it by force. However, Inspector Gregson and the police arrived just in time. Gregson, under secret orders to investigate the stealing of government secrets, confiscates the disk, as Scotland Yard had already deduced Magnus McGilded's involvement and are searching for items he owned as evidence.
Later at night at the same place, Gina came over to Windibank's to see if the unfinished script "The Hound of the Baskervilles" is there, only for the Skulkin brothers to break in, with Ashley Graydon behind them. During this time, Graydon took the music disk from the small box, which had already been forfeited since McGilded died before he could claim it. Windibank fights with the Skulkin brothers, knocking many items off the front counter, and shot his gun into the side of Graydon's arm, hitting the calendar near the door. When Windibank headed inside the storeroom, Graydon shot him in the back, killing him. Gina closed and locked the door and picked up Windibank's gun for protection, but fainted in the storeroom upon realizing he was dead.
Graydon then left the scene entirely, instructing the Skulkin brothers to clean the counter after their fight and to not reveal his presence. Shorty afterwards, Ryunosuke, Susato and Sholmes entered. Sholmes is shot by the brothers, but the bullet hits his pouch instead, and the chemical explosion gives off the impression he was shot. While Ryunosuke pursued the Skulkin brothers, Susato, who got hold of Iris's Cat-Flapomat during one of Gina's pickpocketing "lessons," fears the situation may turn out like the trial two months ago. She decides to put a peephole on the storeroom door right after the incident is over, before Ryunosuke came back to look in the storeroom. They find Windibank shot dead in the back and Gina fainted with Windibank's gun in her hand.
Unexpectedly, Graydon was called to court after the possibility of him being at the scene was discovered through Iris's blood testing. During Gina's testimony, Graydon recognizes Inspector Gregson, and surmises he is looking for the disks. Graydon strikes a deal with him, giving the second disk to Gregson in exchange for information about the crime scene so he may incriminate Gina. Through this deal, Graydon makes the claim that he saw Gina shoot Windibank through the peephole, getting his blood on her coat. Iris's blood testing shows it is Mason's blood, not Windibank's, but since that evidence is not recognized by the court, the blood will incriminate Gina regardless. It is also at this time that Gregson, fearing discovery, surreptitiously hides the disk on Nash Skulkin's person under the pretense of a violent outburst. However, since since the peephole did not even exist at the time Graydon was in the pawnbroker's, he would not have been able to see anything, let alone Gina's bloody coat. His very knowledge of this exposes both himself and Gregson!
After the trial[edit]
Once everything is said and done, only Van Zieks and you will remain in the courtroom. He will finally start to acknowledge your talent, even though your cultures are very different. You will say that you're all human beings, no matter where you come from.
Van Zieks will admit to you that he only took this case to cross swords with you once more. Since the day he met you, apparently you remind him of another "Nipponese" who used to be his friend, but betrayed him terribly. He wanted to understand why he did so, by looking through you. He doesn't want to tell you what happened, but assures you in an eerie warning that you will one day know the answer, "whether you like it or not". Maybe you two were destined to meet after all. And you will surely see each other again in a courtroom.
Outside of the room, you will talk to Gina, and Sholmes and Iris will soon join you. Iris wanted to throw Gina a party, but she still has to go to prison and make amends for some pending offences. She's considering a new career, and hopes maybe she can leave the pickpocket business soon.
Iris will also inform you that the sea is especially choppy and all sailings out of Dover have been delayed. If you rush, you might still be able to say goodbye to Susato and tell her about the case resolution!
That's exactly what you do, and you arrive in Dover just in time to see her about to throw her British law book into the sea. She feels so bad for tampering with a crime scene, and has also felt that she has lost her faith in law and justice, so she doesn't think she's worthy of practicing law anymore. She will confess to creating the peephole because she was worried about Gina, and wanted to see if she was inside the storeroom and check if she was okay. Also, had Susato been in the courtroom with the cat door machine, the ending would've been very different and would've impacted Gina's freedom from crime she didn't commit.
The mystery isn't over, yet. Iris, clever as she is, though limited in Japanese, transcribed the message on the fly as it was being played —at least, the part of it that was played before Gregson confessed— and has deciphered one word out of it: Asogi. Susato happens to know Japanese morse code, and will decipher the rest of the message. It's a list with the names of four people: K. Asogi, A. Shin, T. Gureguson —aka. Gregson— and J. Wilson —Iris's dad. The rest of the transcribed message just says "That is all four..." and stops there.
What dark and convoluted mystery ties these four men together? Whatever it is, it will have to wait until the next installment of the series to be solved. For now, Susato has to go back to Japan. A cutscene will roll, and with this, you have officially completed the game!